AI vs Human Cost Calculator
Compare the true annual cost of hiring employees versus deploying AI automation for the same tasks. Includes salary, benefits, overhead, and AI infrastructure costs.
Human Team
AI Automation
FAQ
Is AI cheaper than hiring employees?
It depends on how much of the work the AI can really take over. Enter the share you have measured with the productivity slider: the calculator compares the human cost you avoid with the AI’s yearly running cost and shows how fast the build cost pays back.
What does an employee really cost?
Base salary plus benefits, payroll taxes and overhead such as equipment, office space, HR and management time. The calculator takes benefits and overhead as percentages of salary so you can enter your own figures.
What goes into the AI cost?
A one-time build or setup cost, monthly API and infrastructure fees, and annual maintenance. From year two the build cost drops out, which is why year-2 costs are lower.
When are people the better choice?
For decisions that need accountability, work built on relationships, tasks without clear success criteria, and regulated processes that require human oversight. Many teams use AI for the repetitive part and keep people for exceptions and review.
How the comparison is calculated
- Human cost = headcount × salary, plus benefits and overhead as percentages of salary. Use your own payroll figures — benefits, payroll taxes and overhead differ a lot between countries and employers.
- AI cost, year 1 = one-time build cost + (monthly API + monthly infrastructure) × 12 + annual maintenance.
- AI cost, year 2+ = the same without the build cost.
- Work covered: the productivity slider says how much of the team's workload the AI can take on. At 50%, only half of the human cost is avoided; values above 100% are capped at the full team cost, because you can't save more than you spend.
- Annual savings = human cost avoided − AI year-2 cost. Payback = build cost ÷ annual savings, in months.
Worked example (the default inputs). Three people at $65,000 with 25% benefits and 20% overhead cost $282,750 a year. The AI side costs $96,000 in year one and $36,000 a year after that. With the slider at 100%, the yearly difference is $246,750 and the build pays back in about 3 months.
Read the result carefully. A 100% setting means the AI fully replaces the work, which is rare. Most deployments take over part of a role while people handle exceptions, review output and keep customer relationships. Set the slider to the share you have actually measured, and keep the review time in the human column.
Limitations. The model doesn't include severance or retraining, quality differences, error costs or the management time an AI system needs. For a fuller business case with operating costs and payback over three years, use the AI ROI calculator.